top of page

Intraday Trading vs. Value Investing in Financial Planning

Writer's picture: Naman GargNaman Garg
Intraday Trading vs. Value Investing in Financial Planning

When discussing stock trading, few people either master it or fall into the category of complete novices. This raises the question: why do the great bulls of the Indian stock market consistently support value investing when intraday trading can potentially yield 2%-5% profit in a single day?


On June 6, 2024, the stock prices of Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) and Power Finance Corporation (PFC) surged by approximately 6%. An investment of 1 lakh rupees could have easily made 6,000 rupees in profit. Even a modest 2% daily profit could turn 1 lakh rupees into 52 lakh rupees over a year, equating to an astonishing return of approximately 5100%. Why then, do investors settle for annual returns of 12%-20% when they could grow their money exponentially?


The Risks of Intraday Trading


The answer lies in the inherent risks of intraday trading. While the potential for high returns exists, so does the possibility of significant losses. A 2% daily loss on an investment of 1 lakh rupees could reduce it to approximately 1,800 rupees over 200 days, equating to a devastating -98% (negative) return.

If you're curious about a mix of intraday profits and losses, don't miss our blog explaining how the probability of consecutive profitable trades drops to 1.56% by the sixth successful trade.


The Stability of Value Investing


Comparatively, value investing offers more stability. With value investing, you can gain or lose around 15% over a year. By choosing quality stocks like HDFC Bank, HUL, Asian Paints, Titan, PFC, and HAL, and holding them for more than five years, investors have historically never lost money and have earned returns between 30% and 1200%.


Example: Stock Price Performance Over the Years


Here's a snapshot of the stock price performance for select stocks from June 6, 2020, to June 6, 2024:


Stock

6 Jun'20

6 Jun'21

6 Jun'22

6 Jun'23

6 Jun'24

CAGR

HDFC Bank

1033

1500

1380

1606

1559

9%

HUL

2087

2342

2291

2716

2555

4%

Asian Paints

1638

2924

2886

3237

2910

12%

Titan

990

1679

2204

2861

3333

27%

PFC

69

98

89

152

473

47%

HAL

315

531

948

1583

4670

71%


Leveraging Professional Expertise in Financial Planning


If selecting stocks and timing your entry and exit isn't your forte, consider relying on experienced fund managers by investing in mutual funds. Fund managers use various valuation methodologies, read earnings reports, evaluate leadership ethics, and future expansion plans before making buy or sell decisions.

I am currently enjoying an XIRR of approximately 22%. You can read more about my investment journey here. If you seek to grow your money through disciplined investing, connect with our expert advisors at Sampann. Download our app from the Play Store to start your investment journey today.


Get in Touch with Sampann


For a free 30-minute consultation with an advisor, contact us at: +91 8951362209.



43 views

Commentaires


Related Posts

Subscribe

Join our email list and get access to Insightful content exclusive to our subscribers.

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page